What’s your favorite?

For SAME DAY orders, please do not order online.
Please call the store or check our mobile app for availability.
Puyallup: 253-256-5566
Univ. Place: 253-453-2332

FOR PRE-ORDERS, PLEASE ORDER BELOW.

Shop

Shop

Filters

Graduation Cupcakes
$62.00
Daily Menu Variety
from $29.50
Gluten Free Variety
from $31.50
Jumbo Cupcakes -- Chocolate or Vanilla
$8.50
Cake Pops
$4.95
Fresh Baked Cookies
from $3.95
Fresh Baked Muffins
from $4.95
Fresh Baked Scones
from $4.95
Fresh Baked Pastries
from $5.00
Party Treat Trays
from $59.95
Cap & Scroll Graduation Cake
from $109.00
View Options
Grad Cap Graduation Cake
from $109.00
View Options
Chocolate Ganache Drip Cake
from $45.00
View Options
Vanilla Ganache Drip Cake
from $45.00
View Options
Salted Caramel Drip Cake
from $45.00
View Options
Toasted Coconut Cake
from $45.00
View Options
German Chocolate Cake
from $45.00
Celebration Cake
from $45.00
View Options
Pink Champagne Cake
from $60.00
View Options
Pumpkin Cake
from $45.00
View Options
S'mores Cake
from $45.00
Boston Cream Cake
from $45.00
View Options
Pallet Knife Floral Cake
from $109.00
View Options
Gender Reveal Cake
from $60.00
View Options
Brownie Tray
$29.99
Rosette Cake
from $45.00
View Options
Happy Birthday Cake
from $45.00
View Options
Unicorn Cake
from $109.00
View Options
Lemon Cake
from $45.00
View Options
Red Velvet Cake
from $45.00
Semi-Naked Cake
from $45.00
View Options
Party Sheet Cake
from $114.00
View Options
Almond Joy
$54.00
Almond Raspberry
from $54.00
Apple Pie
$54.00
Banana Chocolate Chip
from $54.00
Banana Cream Pie
$54.00
Banana Split
$54.00
Black & White
$54.00
Black Forest
$54.00
Blueberry Streusel
$54.00
Boston Cream
$54.00
Butterfinger
from $54.00
Caramel Apple
$54.00
Caramel Brownie
from $54.00
Caramel Macchiato
from $54.00
24Carrot
from $54.00
24Carrot Pecan
from $54.00
Chai
from $54.00
Cherry Cordial
$54.00
Cherry Limeade
$54.00
Chip Chip Cherry
from $54.00
Chocolate Chip Swirl
from $54.00
Chocolate Coconut Cream
$54.00
Chocolate Dipped Banana
from $54.00
Chocolate Dipped Strawberry
from $54.00
Chocolate with Chocolate
from $5.15
Chocolate with Vanilla
from $5.15
Chocolate Orange Cream Cheese
from $54.00
Candy Crazy
from $54.00
Chocolate Dipped Orange
$54.00
Chocolate Dipped Raspberry
$54.00
Chocolate Mounds
from $54.00
Chocolate Raspberry Swirl
from $54.00
Cinnamon Roll
from $54.00
Coconut Cream Pie
$54.00
Coo Coo for Coconut
from $54.00
Cookie Dough
$54.00
Cookies & Cream
$54.00
Cranberry Bliss
from $54.00
Creme Brulee
$54.00
Cupcake Sundae
$54.00
Dirt Cup
from $54.00
Dr. Blackberry
$54.00
Dr. Z's Sweet Tooth
from $54.00
Dream Weaver
from $54.00
Dutch Apple
$54.00
French Toast
from $54.00
Drumstick
$54.00
Eggnog
$54.00
Sold out
Fairy Floss
from $54.00
Gluten Free Chocolate with Vanilla
from $5.25
Gluten Free Salted Caramel
from $5.25
Gluten Free Vanilla with Chocolate
from $31.50
Gluten Free Chocolate with Chocolate
from $5.25
German Chocolate
$54.00
Gingerbread
from $54.00
Sold out
Gluten Free Vanilla with Vanilla
from $31.50
Grasshopper
from $54.00
Happy Birthday!
from $5.15
Hot Cocoa
$54.00
Hummingbird
from $54.00
Java Chip
from $54.00
Key Lime
from $54.00
Lavender Earl Grey
from $54.00
Lemon Blackberry
from $54.00
Lemon Blueberry Swirl
from $54.00
Lemon Coconut
$54.00
Lemon Drop
$54.00
Lemon Earl Grey
$54.00
Lemon Lavender
from $54.00
Lemon Raspberry
from $54.00
Lemonlicious
from $5.15
Luck 'O the Irish
from $54.00
Sold out
Chili Mango Lime
from $54.00
Mimosa
from $54.00
Mint Cookies
from $54.00
Mocha Latte
$54.00
Moose Tracks
from $54.00
Neapolitan
$54.00
Old School
$54.00
Orangesicle
$54.00
Oreo Explosion
$54.00
Payday
$54.00
PB & J
$54.00
Peach Cobbler
from $54.00
Peaches & Cream
from $54.00
Peanut Butter Brownie
from $54.00
Peanut Butter Cup
from $54.00
Peanut Butter Fudge
from $54.00
Peppermint Mocha
from $54.00
Sold out
Pina Colada
from $54.00
Pineapple Delight
from $54.00
Pink Champagne
from $54.00
Pretzel Toffee
from $54.00
Pumpkin Chocolate Chip
from $54.00
Pumpkin Pie
from $54.00
Queen of Hearts
$54.00
Raspberry Cheesecake
$54.00
Raspberry Coconut
$54.00
Red Velvet
from $5.15
Rocky Road
from $54.00
Rolo
$54.00
Root Beer Float
from $54.00
Salted Caramel
from $5.15
Samoa
from $54.00
S'mores
from $54.00
Snickerdoodle
from $54.00
Snickers
$54.00
Spotted Horse
from $54.00
Spumoni
$54.00
Strawberry Champagne
from $54.00
Strawberry Cheesecake
$54.00
Strawberries & Cream
from $54.00
Strawberry Daiquiri
from $54.00
Strawberry Lemonade
from $54.00
Strawberry Shortcake
$54.00
Strawberry Swirl
from $54.00
The King
from $54.00
Thin Mint
from $54.00
Tiramisu
$54.00
Triple Chocolate Mousse
$54.00
Turtle
from $54.00
Chocolate Gluten Free Variety Pack
from $31.50
Vanilla Blackberry
from $54.00
Vanilla Latte
from $54.00
Vanilla with Chocolate
from $5.15
Vanilla with Vanilla
from $5.15
White Chocolate Raspberry
from $54.00

No results found

No results match your search. Try removing a few filters.

Custom Cakes

Looking for something a little more specific?
Prices for custom design cakes are quoted individually.

order custom cakes